Writing/Composition: Evaluating Resources
Not all Library Books are Good Sources!
Here’s a blog that proves that not all books you find in a library are appropriate to use in a paper. Some are extremely out of date or biased. Remember to examine the book’s accuracy, authority, objectivity, currency and coverage before you decide to use it as a source!
Are Your Sources Quality Sources?
When you start researching topics, you will find tons of information in the library, in databases, and online. Some of it is great, but there is also a lot of junk out there. What is important is that you find and use quality information for your assignments. How can you do this?
Use these criteria to examine your sources:
Accuracy – Where is the author getting this information? Are there citations or bibliographies included?
Authority – Who wrote it? What are this author’s credentials?
Objectivity – What opinions are expressed by the author? Is there an ulterior motive?
Currency – When was it published? Are there major events or discoveries about the topic that happened between when it was published and now?
Coverage – Is this a fair and balanced look at the topic? Are a variety of areas within this topic covered?
Evaluating Your Sources – Help on the Web
Here are some websites that explain more about how to think critically and evaluate your sources:
Evaluating a Source While Reading
The Online Writing Lab at Purdue gives lots of good questions to ask yourself when reading a source.Scholarly Journals Vs. Popular Magazine Articles
The Univeristy of Texas at San Antonio provides this website to understand the differences between a scholarly journal article and a popular magazine article.Evaluating Sources: Can I Really Trust This Information?
This site by the University System of Georgia not only tells you what to look for, but where to find itEvaluating Web Pages: Techniques to Apply and Questions to Ask
UC Berkley has this great page on all sorts of ways to evaluate a web page